Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Yoshino and Covering

When Kenji Yoshino expresses the sentiment that “the mainstream is a myth” in his passage The Pressure to Cover, he is not saying that there is no such thing as mainstream, but rather, that there is no one who is truly part of the mainstream. Because the mainstream is continually shifting, people will invariably have some part of them, which does not fit with the mainstream. Though there are people who fill nearly fit perfectly in with the “mainstream crowd,” no one will ever truly fit completely. I agree with his reasoning and found it to be fairly persuasive, especially when he stated that the word mainstream can be used in reference to a particular identity, but cannot be used generically. This definition agrees with my definition because, as he said, mainstream can be used for specific characteristics. To use his example, being straight is more mainstream than being gay, but just because you are straight doesn’t mean you are completely mainstream. Throughout his piece, Yoshino makes valid arguments that are intended to help bring about social change helpful to all, which is something the world should definitely be focusing on.

1 comment:

Molly Sanders said...

I agree that he was saying that no one is truly part of the mainstream and that it is constantly changing. Yoshino does make an assumption that mainstream is the majority, but is made up with separate individuals and the mainstream doesn't allow those individuals to represent their ideals. What I found about his article that made it unpersuasive was that no one is forced to join the mainstream. I thought that Yoshino made it sound like an individual was forced to join the mainstream in order to hide a characteristic. Something becomes mainstream when a group of people believe one thing, but the individual has the choice to join it or not. This is why not everyone fits perfectly in the mainstream.